Skip to main content

Table 2 Methodological quality assessment for the FEM studies (Newcastle-Ottawa scale)

From: Cognitive impairment in first-episode mania: a systematic review of the evidence in the acute and remission phases of the illness

Group

First author (year)

Selection

Comparable

Exposure/outcome

Total stars (out of 9)

Validation of case definition or cohort exposure

Representative sample

Selection of controls or non-exposed cohort

Definition of controls or non-exposed cohort

Groups comparable in design and analysis

Assessment of exposure or outcome

Same method used for both groups or adequate follow-up period

Non-response rate or loss to follow-up

Ā 

Acute

Fleck et al. (2008)

*

*

āˆ’

*

**

āˆ’

āˆ’

āˆ’

5

Lebowitz et al. (2001)

*

āˆ’

āˆ’

āˆ’

**

āˆ’

*

āˆ’

4

Strakowski et al. (2008)

āˆ’

āˆ’

*

*

**

āˆ’

*

*

6

Remission

Elshahawi et al. (2011)

āˆ’

āˆ’

āˆ’

*

**

āˆ’

*

āˆ’

4

Hellvin et al. (2012)

*

*

*

*

**

āˆ’

*

āˆ’

7

Lopez-Jaramillo et al. (2010)

*

*

āˆ’

*

**

āˆ’

*

āˆ’

6

Torres et al. (2010)

āˆ’

*

*

*

**

āˆ’

*

āˆ’

6

  1. *criteria was met; **criteria was met and awarded two stars (comparability only); āˆ’criteria was not met.